Restaurant Job Red Flags to Watch Before You Accept

2 weeks ago

By Carolina Santos

Here is the rule to hold every restaurant offer against: you must be paid for every hour you work, you keep your tips except through a lawful pool, and the kitchen must be safe enough to work in. Those three points come straight from federal law, mainly the Fair Labor Standards Act and the Occupational Safety and Health Act. Most restaurants follow them. The ones that do not usually show it early, in the interview, the trial shift or the first paycheck, if you know what to look for.

Red flags at a glance

Warning sign Why it matters Where to report
Cash pay with no pay stub, or a flat “shift rate” regardless of hours Can hide unpaid overtime and missing minimum wage DOL Wage and Hour Division or state labor department
Manager or owner takes a cut of the tip pool Illegal under federal law DOL Wage and Hour Division
Clocking out before side work or closing duties Off-the-clock work is unpaid labor DOL Wage and Hour Division or state labor department
Blocked exits, broken equipment, no burn or first aid supplies Injury risk; possible OSHA violations OSHA
Teenagers on fryers or meat slicers Federal child labor limits DOL Wage and Hour Division
Schedule posted the night before, shifts cut without notice Unstable income; may break local scheduling laws City or state labor office where such laws exist
Harassment brushed off as “kitchen culture” Illegal discrimination or harassment EEOC or state civil rights agency

Pay red flags

No records of what you are paid

Being paid in cash is not illegal by itself, but being paid without any record of hours and deductions is a warning sign. Employers covered by the FLSA must keep accurate records of hours and wages. If no one can tell you how your hours are tracked, assume they are not.

“Shift pay” or “day rate” for hourly kitchen work

A flat amount per shift can look fine until a shift runs long. Most cooks, dishwashers and servers are non-exempt and must receive time and a half for hours over 40 in a workweek. A salary does not change that unless the job truly meets the exemption tests, which a line cook role usually does not. The DOL’s FLSA overview lays out the basics.

Off-the-clock work

Watch for being told to clock out and then finish prep, roll silverware, clean the walk-in or count the drawer. That time is work time.

Deductions that sink your pay

Charging staff for walkouts, broken plates, register shortages or uniforms can be illegal when it pushes pay below the minimum wage, and tipped employees cannot have walkouts or shortages deducted when the employer takes a tip credit.

Long unpaid “trials”

A short observation may be lawful, but if you are producing food or serving guests, you are probably working and should be paid. Our guide to the kitchen stage and trial shifts covers where that line falls.

Tip red flags

Our article on tip pooling rules explains who can legally share tips.

Safety red flags

Restaurant kitchens have predictable hazards: burns, cuts, slips, lifting injuries and heat. OSHA’s restaurant safety eTool describe the controls employers should use. During your interview or trial shift, look for:

Scheduling and management red flags

Some places now have fair workweek laws. Oregon has a statewide scheduling law, and cities such as New York, Chicago, Seattle and San Francisco have local ones that cover certain food service employers, requiring advance notice and sometimes extra pay for last-minute changes. Check your city’s labor office.

Frequently asked questions

Can I be fired for reporting a wage problem?

Retaliating against a worker for filing a wage complaint or an OSHA complaint is illegal. Keep copies of your schedule, pay stubs and any texts about hours or tips.

Do I need to be documented to file a wage complaint?

The FLSA’s minimum wage and overtime protections cover workers regardless of immigration status, and the Wage and Hour Division keeps the identity of complainants confidential. If you are worried, a local legal aid office or worker center can explain your options before you file.

Who handles food safety problems?

Your local or county health department inspects restaurant kitchens and takes complaints about food handling. Worker safety goes to OSHA or your state’s OSHA plan.

What phone numbers should I keep?

The DOL Wage and Hour Division is 1-866-487-9243. OSHA is 1-800-321-6742. The EEOC is 1-800-669-4000.

A simple next step

Before you accept your next offer, ask three questions out loud: how are my hours recorded, how and when are tips paid out, and who is in the tip pool? Then use our list of questions to ask before accepting a restaurant job to cover the rest. A restaurant that answers clearly and puts it in writing is one worth working for.

About the Author

Author

Trending Articles: