Tip Pooling Rules: Who Can Share Tips and Who Cannot

3 weeks ago

By Carolina Santos

You finish a Friday double, count out your tips and drop them in the house pool like everyone else. On Monday you notice the shift manager who ran the floor that night got a share. Then you hear the kitchen might be added to the pool next month. Is any of that legal? Under federal law, the manager’s cut is not, no matter how the restaurant pays you. Whether the kitchen can join depends on one question: how the restaurant pays the people in the pool.

Tip pooling is one of the most misunderstood parts of restaurant pay, and it changed significantly in 2018. Here is how the federal rules work now, what states can add and how to check your own pool.

What changed in 2018

In March 2018, Congress passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2018, which included an amendment to section 3(m) of the Fair Labor Standards Act. The Department of Labor describes the effect in its tips guidance: the 2018 amendments expressly prohibit employers, including managers and supervisors, from keeping employees’ tips. Before that, the rules were murkier, especially for restaurants that paid the full minimum wage and took no tip credit.

The amendment also gave DOL authority to assess civil money penalties against employers who keep employees’ tips. DOL then implemented the changes through rules in 2020 and 2021, and the parts covering managers and tip pools are now in force.

The one rule that never bends: managers keep their hands off

Under federal law, an employer may not keep any part of employees’ tips, directly or through a pool. That includes managers and supervisors, and it applies whether or not the restaurant takes a tip credit. A manager or supervisor:

Who counts as a manager or supervisor

Job titles do not decide it. DOL uses a duties test: a person whose primary duty is managing the restaurant or a department, who regularly directs the work of two or more full-time employees (or the equivalent), and who can hire or fire or whose recommendations on hiring, firing and promotion carry real weight. Owners with at least a 20 percent stake who actively manage the business also count. A “shift lead” who only runs a station and has no say over staffing may not meet the test; a floor manager who writes the schedule and recommends hires probably does.

Who can join the pool depends on the tip credit

The DOL’s Fact Sheet #15 describes two kinds of pools. The difference is whether the restaurant takes a tip credit, which is the practice of paying tipped staff a cash wage below the minimum and counting tips toward the rest. Our explainer on the tipped minimum wage covers that system.

Traditional pool: restaurant takes a tip credit

If the restaurant pays any pool participant less than the full $7.25 cash wage, the pool may include only employees who customarily and regularly receive tips. DOL’s examples include servers, bellhops, counter staff, bussers and service bartenders. Cooks, dishwashers and other back-of-house staff cannot be included. If they are, the restaurant can lose the right to take the tip credit at all.

Nontraditional pool: restaurant pays full minimum wage

If the restaurant takes no tip credit and pays every participant at least the full minimum cash wage, the pool may include employees who do not customarily receive tips, such as cooks and dishwashers. This is what the 2018 change made clearly possible at the federal level. Managers, supervisors and owners are still excluded.

Other federal rules for any pool

How states can change the picture

Federal law sets the floor. States can be stricter, and several are. Some limit which jobs can share a pool; Massachusetts, for example, restricts pools to wait staff, service bartenders and bus staff. Some do not allow a tip credit at all, which means every restaurant there pays full minimum wage before tips, and the state’s own rules decide whether kitchen staff can join. Before you accept the pool’s rules as written, look at your state labor department’s page on tips.

A hypothetical pool, checked line by line

Say a hypothetical restaurant in a $2.13 state runs a pool with these participants: servers, bussers, the bartender, a line cook and the assistant manager. Checking against the federal rules:

Now say the same restaurant raises every participant to at least $7.25 cash and stops taking a tip credit. The line cook can now be included. The assistant manager still cannot.

Putting it into practice

Ask for the pool rules in writing when you are hired: who participates, what percentage each role receives and whether the restaurant takes a tip credit. Keep a simple record of your tips and pool payouts each week. If a manager is getting a share or kitchen staff are in a tip-credit pool, raise it with the owner in writing first. If nothing changes, you can contact the DOL Wage and Hour Division at 1-866-487-9243 or your state labor agency. Retaliating against you for complaining is itself a violation, and our list of restaurant job red flags covers the other warning signs worth watching.

About the Author

Author

Trending Articles: